Socrates: Impact on Philosophy and Education
Socrates: Impact on Philosophy and Education
Major contribution to philosophy
He redirected philosophical inquiry away from natural science toward ethics and ethical conduct.
Three influential students
- Plato
- Aristophanes
- Xenophon
These students shaped Greek and Roman thought and, through them, modern philosophy.
Modern resonances
- Utilitarian thinkers treated Socrates as a Christ-like martyr. (Utilitarianism in education: education must be for a purpose and a utility.)
- Karl Jaspers, the German existentialist, called Socrates a “paradigmatic individual.” (Existentialism: the world lives inside the human; without understanding the inner world, there is no link to the outer.)
- Michel Foucault, the French philosopher, was fascinated by the Socratic tradition of self-reflection and care of the self.
A man who wrote nothing left a longer shadow than most who wrote everything. Socrates’ impact on the way teachers think shows up in three places: a permanent redirection of what philosophy was about, three students whose work still appears in modern syllabi, and three modern thinkers who reach back across twenty-four centuries to draw from him.
The major contribution: from natural science to ethics
Before Socrates, Greek philosophy mostly asked questions about the natural world. What is everything made of? Water, said Thales. Fire, said Heraclitus. Air, said Anaximenes. Atoms, said Democritus. The Pre-Socratics were doing a kind of early physics dressed in the language of philosophy.
Socrates pulled philosophy away from those questions. The natural world would still be there tomorrow, he thought. The harder question was how to live in it. He turned philosophy’s attention toward ethics and questions of ethical conduct: what is justice, what is courage, what is the good life.
This redirection was not minor. It set the agenda for the European philosophical tradition for the next two and a half thousand years. When Plato wrote about the ideal city, when Aristotle wrote about virtue, when Kant wrote about moral duty, when Sartre wrote about authentic choice, they were all working inside the territory Socrates had marked out.
Redirecting inquiry toward ethics
Pre-Socratic Greek philosophy mostly asked what the natural world is made of. Socrates pulled the focus toward how a human being should live: justice, courage, the good life. The European tradition has been working inside that frame ever since.
The three influential students
Socrates had many students. Three are remembered as decisive for the history of education and philosophy.
Plato is the most important. He preserved Socrates’ method in his dialogues, then built on it. The doctrine of the Forms, the allegory of the cave, the Republic: all rest on a Socratic foundation. Plato gets a long sequence of chapters later in this guide.
Aristophanes was actually not a philosophical student in the strict sense. He was a comic playwright, and he wrote a play (The Clouds) that mocked Socrates as a sophistical schoolmaster. The play matters because it helped shape public opinion against Socrates and contributed, indirectly, to his trial. He is often listed among Socrates’ three influential students because he sat in his audience and engaged with his ideas, even when his engagement took the form of satire.
Xenophon was a soldier and historian. He wrote a set of Memorabilia about Socrates that complement Plato’s dialogues. Where Plato’s Socrates is often pursuing abstract definitions, Xenophon’s Socrates is more practical and conversational. The two portraits together give a fuller picture of the man.
Through these three, Socrates’ methods spread first across Greek thought, then to Roman thought, then to medieval Christian and Islamic philosophers who read the Greeks, and on into modern philosophy.
Plato, Aristophanes, Xenophon
Plato preserved Socrates’ method in his dialogues and built on it.
Aristophanes was a comic playwright who satirised Socrates in The Clouds.
Xenophon was a soldier-historian whose Memorabilia shows a more practical Socrates.
Three modern thinkers who still draw from him
Socrates’ impact did not end in ancient Greece. Three modern thinkers, from very different traditions, treat him as a reference point.
Utilitarian thinkers: Socrates as Christ-like martyr
Utilitarianism is a school of moral philosophy that judges actions by their consequences. Education, in the utilitarian view, must be for a purpose and a utility. The classical utilitarian writers (Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill, and others) treated Socrates as a kind of martyr. He died for an idea, refused to compromise his teaching to save his own life, and accepted a public death for the sake of a private truth. The Christ-like framing made him a model for any thinker willing to suffer for an honest position.
Karl Jaspers: Socrates as paradigmatic individual
Karl Jaspers, a twentieth-century German existentialist, ranked Socrates among the few figures he called “paradigmatic individuals”: people whose lives serve as a model of what a human being can be. The list, for Jaspers, included Buddha, Confucius, Jesus, and Socrates. The existentialist reading focuses on Socrates’ insistence on the inner life. The world, for existentialism, lives inside the human. Without an understanding of the inner world, there is no real link to the outer. Socrates’ work of self-examination is exactly what that reading values.
Michel Foucault: Socrates and the care of the self
Michel Foucault, a twentieth-century French philosopher, was fascinated by Socrates’ tradition of self-reflection. Foucault used the phrase “care of the self” (in French, le souci de soi) to describe a way of life in which a person actively tends to their own thinking, their own habits, and their own ethical formation. He read Socrates as one of the earliest serious practitioners of that work in the Western tradition.
He died rather than compromise his teaching
Utilitarianism judges actions by their consequences and treats education as a purposeful activity. Socrates’ refusal to soften his ideas to save his life made him a model of intellectual integrity for that tradition.
A paradigmatic individual
Jaspers ranked Socrates with Buddha, Confucius, and Jesus as models of what a human being can be. The existentialist reading focuses on Socrates’ insistence on the inner life: the world lives inside the human.
Care of the self
In French, le souci de soi. Foucault used it to describe a life in which a person actively tends to their own thinking, habits, and ethical formation. He read Socrates as one of the earliest serious practitioners of that work.
How was this article?