Socrates and the Examined Life
Socrates: Introduction and the Examined Life
The basics
- Born 469 BC, died 399 BC, Athens.
- Greek philosopher and teacher.
- Called the father of philosophy.
Method
- Critical reasoning with an unwavering commitment to truth.
- Analysed fellow Athenians and questioned popular concepts.
Records
- Wrote nothing himself.
- Known through his students, especially Plato and Xenophon.
The famous line
“The unexamined life is not worth living for a human being.” (quoted in Plato’s Apology)
Goal of education
To know what you can, and even more importantly, to know what you do not know.
Trial and death
Sentenced to drink poison hemlock at seventy. The accusation was that he was corrupting the youth.
A man in his seventies stood trial in Athens for the crime of asking too many questions. The jury convicted him. He was given a cup of hemlock and told to drink. He drank, said a few last words to his students, and died. The man was Socrates, and the conviction did not silence him. His students wrote down what he had said, and twenty-four centuries later teachers still teach the way he taught.
The basics
Socrates was born in 469 BC in Athens and died in 399 BC. He was a Greek philosopher and teacher. He is often called the father of philosophy, not because there were no thinkers before him (there were), but because he set the pattern for what philosophy would mean in the European tradition: a discipline of careful questioning aimed at truth.
He wrote nothing. Everything we know of him comes from his students. The two most important are Plato and Xenophon. Plato wrote a series of dialogues with Socrates as the main speaker. Xenophon wrote memoirs. Their portraits of him do not match perfectly, which has kept scholars busy for a long time, but the broad picture is clear.
469 to 399 BC, Athens
He lived about seventy years. The bulk of his work was the last twenty: walking the city, asking questions, building no school, writing nothing down.
The examined life
The line most often associated with Socrates comes from Plato’s Apology, where Socrates is on trial:
The unexamined life is not worth living for a human being.
The line is the heart of his method. He believed a life of habit, of unthought beliefs, of popular opinions absorbed without inspection, was not really a life. A human being who never asked what they truly believed and why was not yet fully a human being.
So he walked Athens and asked people questions. What is courage? What is justice? What is piety? When they answered, he probed the answer until it broke. The point was not to humiliate. The point was to show that confident opinion is not the same as careful knowledge.
“The unexamined life is not worth living for a human being”
The line is from Plato’s Apology, spoken by Socrates at his trial. It captures his whole method: a life of unthought belief is not yet a full human life.
The goal of education
Socrates defined the goal of education in one line: to know what you can, and even more importantly, to know what you do not know.
The first half is ordinary. Every teacher wants their students to know things. The second half is the Socratic move. The hardest thing for a young mind is not learning new facts. It is admitting where the gaps are. A student who confidently believes a wrong thing is harder to teach than a student who confesses ignorance.
So the Socratic goal of education turns the usual order on its head. It values self-knowledge of one’s ignorance more than the accumulation of confident opinion. A graduate of a Socratic school would not be the one with the most answers. It would be the one with the clearest sense of which questions are still open.
To know what you can, and especially to know what you do not know
The first half is ordinary. The second half is the Socratic move: a student who confesses ignorance is more teachable than a student who confidently believes a wrong thing.
The trial and the hemlock
Athens lost a war with Sparta. The city was unsettled. The leaders looked around for someone to blame, and an old man who had been asking awkward questions of public figures for forty years was a convenient target. The charge was that Socrates was corrupting the youth and not believing in the city’s gods.
He could have apologised and gone home. He refused. At seventy, with a death sentence in front of him, he kept arguing his case as he had argued his life. The jury voted to convict. The punishment was hemlock, a poison.
A century later, the painter Jacques-Louis David painted The Death of Socrates. The painting shows him in prison, surrounded by grieving students, reaching for the cup of poison while still mid-sentence. The image captured how Socrates’ death has been remembered ever since: a man who would not stop asking, even to save his own life.
Charged with corrupting the youth and impiety
Athens convicted him after he refused to soften his teaching. He was made to drink hemlock at seventy. His refusal to apologise is part of why he is remembered.
How was this article?