State Schools and the Guardians
Aristotle: State Schools and Guardians
Education as a state function
The state should have complete control of education and use it to prepare the kind of citizens it needs.
Cultured citizens
For the Greek citizen, education aimed at becoming a fuller and more cultured person. Vocational education was treated as fit only for the lower classes.
Guardians of education
A select group of citizens, chosen for the purpose, who administer the educative process for the state.
Once a state has decided that education is a public matter, the next questions are practical: who runs the schools, what kind of person should they aim to produce, and how much control should the state hold? Aristotle’s answers are strong, and they have shaped the structure of public education in the West ever since.
Complete state control of education
Aristotle’s answer to the question of state involvement is the strongest possible. The state should have complete control of education and use it to prepare the kind of citizens it needs.
The word complete is striking. Aristotle is not asking for state funding alongside private schools. He is not asking for a state-set curriculum that private schools must follow. He is asking for the state to run the whole educational enterprise, top to bottom, from the earliest grades to the highest levels of philosophical training.
The reasoning follows from his earlier goals. The state needs virtuous, intelligent citizens. The state has the strongest possible interest in the production of those citizens. The state therefore has the strongest possible reason to keep that production in its own hands. Outsourcing the most important political task is, by this reasoning, a strategic error.
A modern reader has many reactions to this. Some will recognise Aristotle’s position as the parent of every public education system in the modern world. Others will see it as authoritarian by comparison with modern systems that mix public and private. Either reaction is fair. What is not fair is to soften the position to make it more palatable.
Complete state control, from the earliest grades to the highest training
Not state funding alongside private schools. Not a state-set curriculum that private schools must follow. The state should run the whole educational enterprise and use it to prepare the kind of citizens it needs. The reasoning: the state has the strongest possible interest in producing virtuous, intelligent citizens, and outsourcing this work is a strategic error.
The cultured citizen and the vocational worker
Aristotle draws a sharp class line through education. Vocational education was fit only for the lower classes. For the Greek citizen, education was about becoming a fuller and more cultured person.
A vocational education trains a person for a particular trade: carpentry, weaving, metalwork, agriculture. The student finishes with a marketable skill and can earn a living by it. Aristotle does not deny that this is useful work; he denies that it is what a citizen’s education should aim at. A citizen’s life is not defined by the trade they practise. It is defined by their participation in the common life of the city.
The citizen’s education aims at making them a fuller and more cultured person. The fuller person has developed all the basic human capacities (reasoning, judgement, taste, memory, civic skill) rather than only the ones a trade requires. The more cultured person has been formed by exposure to the best the human tradition has produced (poetry, music, history, philosophy, the constitutions of cities). The result is a citizen who can take part in the highest political conversations and make wise judgements about the common life.
This is the origin of what later traditions called liberal education, in the original sense of the word: education suitable for a free person (liber) rather than a slave. The free person needs the full range of human development. The slave or labourer needs only what their work requires. Aristotle drew the distinction sharply, and the distinction has shaped the structure of education in the West ever since.
Becoming a fuller and more cultured person, not training for a trade
Vocational education trains a person for a particular trade and produces a worker with a marketable skill. Citizen education develops all the basic human capacities (reasoning, judgement, taste, civic skill) and forms the student by exposure to the best of human tradition. This is the origin of liberal education in the original sense: education for a free person rather than a slave.
The guardians of education
The final piece of Aristotle’s account is administrative. Who actually runs the schools? Aristotle’s answer is the guardians of education: a select group of citizens, chosen for the purpose, who administer the educative process for the state.
The word guardians is Platonic in flavour. Plato’s Republic uses the same image for the ruling class of his ideal city. Aristotle borrows the word but uses it more narrowly. Plato’s guardians rule the whole state. Aristotle’s guardians of education are responsible only for the educational system. They oversee curricula, supervise teachers, examine students, and make sure the work of producing citizens is being done well.
The guardians are themselves citizens, chosen from the best. They are not a separate professional class of educators set apart from political life. They are people who have already lived as citizens, demonstrated their virtue, and are now turning their attention to the production of the next generation. The choice is deliberate. The state cannot outsource the formation of citizens to people who are not themselves model citizens.
The role parallels a modern board of education or ministry of education, but with one important difference. The guardians are not bureaucrats whose specialism is education administration. They are wise citizens whose specialism is virtue and judgement, applied to the educational system as part of their wider service to the state.
The picture Aristotle paints, taken as a whole, is of a state in which education is the most important shared project. The state defines its needs. The guardians design the curriculum. The teachers cultivate rationality in the students. The students grow into citizens. The citizens take part in political life, choose new guardians, and the cycle continues. The state is held together by this cycle of education, not by force or by economic transaction. Take away the cycle and the state stops working.
A select group of citizens who administer the educative process for the state
They are not a separate professional class. They are wise, virtuous citizens who have demonstrated their fitness and now turn their attention to the formation of the next generation. They oversee curricula, supervise teachers, examine students, and ensure the educational work is being done well. The role parallels a modern board of education, but the guardians are statesmen, not bureaucrats.
How was this article?